|
|
|
| Historical
Fiction
New
reviews, written by Belmont teens since June, 2003, appear first.
Previous reviews follow in alphabetical order by author. |
| |
 |
Title:
Fever 1793
Author: Laurie Halse Anderson
Reviewer's Age: Grade 8
Fever 1793, takes place at
Pennsylvania, in 1793 (hence the title, Fever 1793). It’s
about a 14-year old girl named Mattie Cook, who’s mother
runs a coffeehouse. Mattie, tired of listening to her mother,
has many plans to turn the coffeehouse into an upscale establishment,
one of the finest in Pennsylvania. All those plans are shattered
though, when a Yellow Fever epidemic breaks out in the city.
Those who do not flee to the country are trapped in the city,
sitting ducks to fever, robbers, and starvation. When the rest
of her family goes to stay with some cousins in the country,
Mattie’s life becomes a living nightmare and a struggle
to survive. Fever
1793 was a good book, as far as historical fiction goes.
It was informative, and had a catchy plot. It was also very
cliché, and had a very happily-ever-after ending. Out
of 10 stars, I’d give Fever 1793 a 6. |
 |
Title: The Shakespeare
Stealer
Author: Gary Blackwood
Reviewer's Age: Grade 8
The Shakespeare Stealer is about a
young orphan named Widge. Because of his rare ability to write
in a unique shorthanded code, he is sent to steal Shakespeare’s
Hamlet by his master, a rival playwright. He sneaks into the
Globe theatre, and is taken in by his fellow actors. In the
end, Widge has to decide where his loyalties lie, with his master
and the large reward that he will get for retrieving the play,
or his new friends. The
Shakespeare Stealer is a catchy story, very improbable,
but fun to read. All of the ends are conveniently wrapped up
by the last page, so all you're left wondering is ‘What
horribly interesting adventure will Widge have next?’;
a nice start for the sequel. Out of 10 stars, I’d give
this book a 6. |
 |
Title: The Chosen
Author: Chaim Potok
Reviewer's Age: Grade 11
This book is about two Jewish boys
who live about five blocks from each other their whole lives.
They live very different lifestyles, though. Danny Sanders belongs
to a very orthodox Hasidic group. Reuven Malthers is a conservative
Jew but lives an American teenage life as well. Their schools
play each other and by accident Danny hits Reuven in the eye
while pitching to him. From that accident they begin to see
each cother more and eventually build a friendship even though
they are really different.
I liked the book because it showed that people should never
be judged by their appearance or what they are thought to be
like – what matters is what’s inside (their personality). |
 |
Title:
An Acquaintance with Darkness
Author: Ann Rinaldi
Reviewer's Age: Grade 8
An Acquaintance with Darkness
by Ann Rinaldi is about Emily Bransby, a 14-year old girl living
in Washington DC at the time that President Lincoln was assassinated.
Her mother has just died and her best friend’s mother
is jailed for taking a part in Lincoln’s murder. Because
her father is also dead, Emily is forced to live with her mother’s
hated brother, Valentine, who is a doctor with a secret. Emily
has to decide how much she’s willing to risk for her law-breaking
uncle. An Acquaintance with Darkness
was a good book, well written with a good plot. Despite what
you may have heard about historical fiction, it actually isn’t
as boring as it could be. Out of 10 stars, I’d give this
book a 7. |
 |
Title: My Brother,
My Sister, and I
Author: Yoko Kawashima Watkins
Reviewer's Age: Grade 9
My Brother, My Sister and I
is an autobiography and is the sequel to So Far from the
Bamboo Grove. It’s about how the main character Yoko,
her brother and sister try to survive together during World
War II. They are all in search of their father after their mother’s
death. They are framed for a murder and try to prove their innocence.
After an incident at the building where they were living, they
stay at the hospital because of the older sister’s injuries.
My Brother, My Sister and I shows the hardships of
surviving for those who are less fortunate. |
More
Reviews in alphabetical order
by author |
| |
|
Title:
Shadrach's Crossing
Author: Avi
Reviewer's Age: Grade 8
The book Shadrach's Crossing
is about a boy named Shad who tries to stop Kinlow, a powerful
man, from smuggling illegal goods into his island in 1932. As
a result of this smuggling, the islanders' lives are put to
danger. This is a great adventurous novel. What I liked in the
book was that Shad would never give up trying even though he
was getting into trouble. What I didn't like was that Shad's
friend would not try to stop Kinlow with him. |
|
Title:
The Bear and the Dragon
Author: Tom Clancy
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
This story unfolds when China goes
to war with Russia. Its main characters are Jack Ryan, prez
of the USA, Hugo Chavez, CIA agent, and many more. As usual
in Tom Clancy novels, the books began with many stories, completely
random. However, as the story progresses, the story lines come
together for a dramatic ending. Clancy's books are awesome,
you can't put them down. I recommend this book for any war reading
enthusiast (ages 14+). |
|
Title:
My Brother Sam is Dead
Author: James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
My Brother Sam is Dead educates
and entertains at the same time. This book is set against the
backdrop of the American Revolution. It gives facts about what
everyday life was like in the colonies. Although the story takes
place in the 1770's the conflicts still apply to life today.
The main character's family is torn. His father is a loyalist,
while his brother is a soldier in the Continental Army. This
is like life today when part of your family wants you to do
something, while the other half wants you to do something else.
For instance one parent might want you to be a lawyer, while
the other might want you to be a doctor. He also has to live
the life of a child of a single parent (his father is captured
and dies). This is a must read for everyone. |
|
Title:
My Brother Sam is Dead
Author: James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
My Brother Sam is Dead is
a book that everybody should read. It is well written, and a
well-plotted book. It is about history of a war and how a family
struggles to survive through it with a son in the war. It tells
about death, loves lost, and family struggles, all in one book.
It has a tragic ending and a good beginning that everyone will
enjoy. |
|
Title:
The Power of One
Author: Bruce Courtenay
Reviewer's Age: 17
This is a really good book for young
adults. It is about a young student boxer in South Africa during
WWII. |
|
Title:
The Watsons Go To Birmingham
Author: Christopher Paul Curtis
Reviewer's Age: Grade 8
This book takes place in 1963 -- during
the civil rights movement. Kenny Watson is a 4th grader at Clark
Elementary School in Flint, Michigan. The beginning of the book
is about his life at home and school: his older brother's problems
and punishments, the teasing at school, the cold of winter,
and his sister Joetta's dinosaur games. The excitement starts
when there is a phone call from Grandma Sands down in Birmingham,
Alabama. Mother announces to the family that they will be taking
a trip down to Birmingham during the summer and that Byron,
Kenny's older brother, will stay with Grandma Sands for the
whole summer to be disciplined. After arriving in Birmingham,
the children have adventures that will change their lives forever.
This book is a "must-read" and has become one of my
favorites. |
|
Title:
An Episode of Sparrows
Author: Rumer Godden
Reviewer's age: Grade 7
I've read Rumer Godden most of my life,
yet An Episode of Sparrows is the first book of hers
that shows the talented writer of adult books she is. She has
created a tale of love, hate, joy, and pain. The story takes
place in London at the turn of the century; this setting makes
the story interesting and different. The story follows an abandoned
child, Lovejoy, whose selfish mother leaves her with a poor,
yet kind family. Lovejoy feels misplaced, and to fill that gap
in her life starts a garden. Even though I don't like Lovejoy's
character, I'm fascinated by it. Lovejoy is a mean, negative
character, yet she knows what she wants and is determined to
get it. With little to start with Lovejoy collects knowlege
and materials and creates her garden and her life. Lovejoy's
determination and cleverness makes this the great book it is. |
|
Title:
Out of the Dust
Author: Karen Hesse
Reviewer's Age: 12
Out of the Dust is a novel
about Billie Jo, a girl who lives in the panhandle of Oklahoma.
It seems that her life gets worse and worse. She has to live
through the dust storms that spoil the wheat crop. When her
mother is giving birth to Billie Jo's brother, he dies shortly
after as well as her mother. Her father is quiet for a time
after, and Billie Jo has noone to talk to. She is a strong character,
and shows that even through the worst, you can survive. Karen
Hesse did this book in a different form. She wrote the book
like poetry lines, except they do not rhyme. This adds a strong
feeling to the book. It is simple, yet powerful. I liked this
about the book. |
|
Title:
On the Road
Author: Jack Kerouac
Reviewer's Age: Grade 12
In On the Road, Jack Kerouac
uses the stories of different road trips to describe a uniquely
positive attitude toward life. The novel is narrated by Sal
Paradise, a writer who lives in the New York area. Sal tells
us about the several road trips he took during the late 1940's
and early 1950's. He makes detailed and perceptive observations
about the people and places he sees. He introduces many funny
characters that take part in his adventures. The most important
person Sal talks about is Dean Moriarty, a crazy young man who
is always moving about (whether it is for better or worse).
Dean embodies the attitude that Sal is trying to depict: Dean
is always excited and feels the need to share his every thought
with the people around him. Furthermore, Dean is never satisfied
staying in one place or relationship; he always seeks something
different and is always eager to experience new things. Despite
the many bad situations he gets himself into, Dean always has
a positive outlook on the future. Finally Dean is a madman on
the wheel, recklessly tearing across thousands of miles of highway
on mere whims. In terms
of giving a picture of the spirit Dean represents, On the
Road is a complete success. Reading this book gives you
a true sense of what many people must have felt at that time:
the urge to live freely without fearing the future or looking
back. However, Kerouac could have accomplished that goal with
a more compact book. Sal's observations do not add up to a final
conclusion in plot, so there is a sense of the book being somewhat
unfinished at the end. Although there is no significant plot
resolution, the positive feeling you get at the end of the book
makes up for it. |
|
Title:
The Bluest Eye
Author: Toni Morrison
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
Toni Morrison's The Bluest Eye
is a deep story. It's about a young black girl who prays for
blue eyes so that she can be pretty. The Bluest Eye
makes people think twice about what true beauty is. Pecola makes
a wish to have blue eyes, which makes her worry about her appearance.
She worries that there might be someone with bluer eyes. "Suppose
my eyes aren't blue enough . . ." She thinks her only friend
will stop speaking to her if her eyes aren't blue enough. The
eyes also made her conceited. "Oh yes . . . My blue eyes.
Prettier than the sky." The Bluest Eye makes people
think twice about what true beauty is. Changing our appearence
to suit other's appeal indicates low self-esteem. The Bluest
Eye is an excellent book that should be read because it
shows the things that people will do to satisfy others expectations. |
|
Title:
A Day no Pigs Would Die
Author: Robert Newton Peck
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
A Day No Pigs Would Die by
Robert Newton Peck has been one of my favorite books and I recommend
this book to students or anybody to read. This book is about
a boy and his father living on a farm in Vermont. The boy's
father's job is to slaughter pigs and prepare them as food.
The farm that they is own is having a very hard time and the
family has to work together. And the boy has to go through difficulties.
He has to go to school but has no money for clothes or extras.
And after school he has to work on the farm, so he has little
time for friends and he gets alienated. This book has deep emotions
and it tells how life is hard and unfair. Also, unlike the other
school recommended books, this book has great humor, which makes
the reader want to keep reading |
|
Title:
The Chosen
Author: Chaim Potok
Reviewer's Age: Grade 10
The Chosen, by Chaim Potok,
is the best book I have every read. The book takes place in
Brooklyn, New York, after the Second World War. It is about
two Jewish boys, one Hasidic and one Orthodox, coming of age.
One is trying to make sense out of the teachings of Judaism
and the aftermath of the war. The other is seeking more and
more knowledge that's forbidden by his religion and looking
for the reason for his father's lack of communication with him.
The book is also about the extraordinary friendship they have,
started coincidentally by a baseball game, built up as they
help each other, and shaken by their political and religious
opposition views. I like this book so much because it has an
unexpected ending that stops the struggles of both people as
well as the downfall of their friendship. |
|
Title:
The Serpent Garden
Author: Judith Merkle Riley
Reviewer's Age: Grade 12
Judith Merkle Riley is a professor
at Claremont McKenna College and she deftly incorporates her
extensive historical knowledge with an engaging plot in the
novel The Serpent Garden. The work of fiction takes
place during the reign of the young King Henry VIII in the midst
of the bustle and clamor that was, and indeed is, London. The
story unfolds around a naive Flemish woman named Susanna whose
reality is suddenly changed by the deaths of her parents, the
murder of her adulterous husband, and the loss of a child while
giving birth. After suffering through the shock of these ordeals,
Susanna transforms from an obedient, submissive wife to a competent,
ambitious and street smart lady who must practice her father's
art of miniature portrait painting in order to support her servant
companion, Nan, and herself. Quickly, a complicated scenario
ensues as Susanna's buried husband's diabolical pursuits ensnare
her in the grips of some of England's most powerful forces.
A surprisingly intricate weave of history and fiction as well
as a highly readable tale, The Serpent Garden imparts a compelling
narrative and draws upon qualities such as lust for power, sustaining
hope and the ability to endure that are timeless. |
|
Title:
An Acquaintance with Darkness
Author: Ann Rinaldi
Reviewer's Age: Grade 7
Emily is a normal 14-year-old girl
living in the 1860s. Then, Lincoln is killed, and Emily's best
friend's mother is accused of helping the conspirators and is
taken to jail. Meanwhile, Emily accuses her uncle of being a
body snatcher and of lying to her. Is he? Read the book and
find out. |
| |
|